Filed in Mind & perception, Therapy  ·  Tagged Meditation & mindfulness

Ten signposts out of the woods

Pen drawing of Reid sitting cross-legged in meditation.

Ten playful meditations I've been teaching and refining for about a decade, reread now as a psychiatrist. You can try every one of them right here on the page.

By Reid Robison, MD. Walk at your own pace; each signpost takes two to ten minutes. Sound is optional and off until you turn it on.

Prefer to wander? Signposts inward is the same path as a quiet, full-screen experience in the art room. Come back here for the stories, the science and the safety notes.

The short version

Two habits to carry and ten small experiments. Pick one and try it today. The note after each name says how much research is behind it.

The rule of 3Do each practice three times. It's a rhythm, not a rule the universe enforces.
Find your breathIn for 3, hold for 3, out for 3. Make the out-breath 6 if you want to calm down further.
  1. 1 · Sunflower well studiedSqueeze, release, reach for the light.
  2. 2 · Meadow promisingBuild a calm place, one sense at a time.
  3. 3 · Mantra well studiedRepeat a word until it's only sound.
  4. 4 · Villager well studiedTry not to think about zen. See how that goes.
  5. 5 · The long "lu" promisingOne note, sung for one long breath out.
  6. 6 · Fruit fly well studiedSend kindness outward, ring by ring.
  7. 7 · Two tortoises promisingThree honest questions, then quiet eye contact.
  8. 8 · Moon early, thin evidenceTrace tonight's moon with your breath.
  9. 9 · Scribe promisingWrite it fast, then let it burn.
  10. 10 · Cloud well studiedFloat up and watch your problem shrink to its actual size.

Well studied: several controlled trials. Promising: some trials, small effects. Early, thin evidence: mostly theory.

How these grew

For about ten years I've taught versions of these practices at meditation gatherings, in yoga classes and on the floor of more than a few studios. They started as little fables I told to make instructions stick. There's a slightly hapless teacher, a relentlessly cheerful sunflower and a pair of tortoises who are very much in love.

The practices evolved over the years. I kept the ones that landed with people and dropped the ones that didn't. Some started as jokes and stayed jokes. One promised you could learn to fly.

Reading them again as a psychiatrist, more of them hold up than I expected. Several of these "invented" meditations turn out to be well-studied techniques with silly names. A couple needed safety notes I wouldn't have thought to add back then. One is pure hooey, and I'll tell you which.

A note on the word zen: Zen is a specific Buddhist tradition, and its core practice is zazen, which means seated meditation. None of what follows is traditional Zen. I use the word in its lowercase sense: lightness, noticing and nothing extra.

A student asked the teacher, "Can you teach me zen?"

"No. Zen can't be taught. Like an island in a lake, it has to be discovered."

"Then can you teach me the way to it?"

"It isn't the way to zen. It's the way of zen. Anyone can walk it. There are signposts."

"And if I miss one?"

"Then you'll be lost in the woods. The path is easy to walk and even easier to wander off."

"Where are the woods?"

"You're standing in them right now, so lost you haven't noticed they're there."

Before you set out

The rule of 3

Do everything three times. The first time, you're reading instructions. The second time, you're doing them. By the third, you're starting to notice something. Three is a good number for a rhythm. It isn't magic.

Find your breath

This is the most important practice on the page, because every other signpost starts and ends with it. Breathe in for 3, hold for 3 and breathe out for 3. Do three rounds. If you want to calm down, stretch the out-breath to 6. Slow breathing with a longer exhale reliably lowers arousal. In one trial, five minutes a day of exhale-focused breathing improved mood more than the same amount of mindfulness meditation.1,2

Try it · find your breath
Ready when you are
About 40 seconds. Eyes can close once you've got the rhythm.
Signpost one

Sunflower well studied

The path of true happiness

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

The teacher asked a sunflower how she could be so happy. "I have the sun!" she said. "And if clouds cover it?" "Then it rains and I get water!" "And at night?" "Then I talk to my friend the moon. He loves the sun as much as I do."

"Teach me to be like you," said the teacher. She told him a sunflower needs only three things: air, water and sun. Then she tried very hard not to laugh at how silly he looked scrunching up his face.

Try it · grow a sunflower
Air · water · sun
Stand up if you can. Each squeeze and release opens a petal. About 3 minutes.
Why it might work

The "water" step is progressive muscle relaxation, developed by Edmund Jacobson in the 1920s and 30s. Deliberately tensing a muscle and then letting it go teaches your body what relaxed actually feels like, and trials consistently find it reduces anxiety and stress.3 The "sun" step adds a big stretch and a burst of effort. The sunflower is right: that's how you get sun.

Go gently

Skip or soften any part of your body that's injured. Keep breathing while you squeeze.

Sit with thisThe sunflower doesn't wait for a better day before turning toward the light. What would you turn toward if you stopped waiting?
Signpost two

Meadow promising

The path of perfect peace

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

The teacher had papers to grade and students knocking on his door, and his office was no place to meditate. So he built a place that was, and found he could walk into it any time he liked.

Try it · build your meadow
Close your eyes between steps
Tap the senses in order. Each one adds a layer to the meadow. Turn sound on to hear the creek.
Why it might work

This is guided imagery, also called a "safe place" exercise, and it's a staple of relaxation training and trauma therapy. Moving through the senses one at a time keeps your attention busy enough that there's less room for worry. The evidence is real but modest: small trials show benefits for stress and pain, usually as part of a larger program. The more specific your meadow, the better it works. Once you've built one, you can get back to it in about ten seconds, and that's when it's most useful.

Sit with thisIf you can build peace in ten seconds, where was it before you built it?
Signpost three

Mantra well studied

The path of new meaning

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

"Pick a mantra, any mantra!" said the teacher. One student objected: "Won't picking anything we want defeat the purpose of a mantra?" "What a wonderful mantra!" said the teacher. The student kept asking whether each new thing he said was a mantra too, until the teacher said, "Ah. You've found yours."

Try it · wear a word out
MeaningNon-meaningNew meaning
Say the word out loud with each pulse, at different speeds and tones. Turn sound on and the page will say it with you.
Why it might work

The "non-meaning" stage is a real, measurable effect called semantic satiation, first described in 1907: repeat a word enough times and it temporarily loses its meaning.4,5 Therapists now use it on purpose. In acceptance and commitment therapy, people repeat a painful label about themselves ("stupid, stupid, stupid…") for about 30 seconds until it's just noise. In a controlled study, that took the believability and sting out of the thought faster than distraction did.6 The "new meaning" stage has a clinical name too: defusion, which means seeing a thought as a thought.

Go gently

If you choose a harsh word about yourself, keep the first round short and try it on a day when you feel steady.

Sit with thisA word is a sound you've agreed to believe. What other sounds have you agreed to believe?
Signpost four

Villager well studied

The path of complete originality

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

A villager asked for a meditation for ordinary people. "There already is one," said the teacher. "But it takes all day. Be normal. Make no art. Believe what you're told. If a thought is new, let it go. And whatever you do, don't think about zen."

By lunchtime, the villager had discovered that being normal was the hardest thing he had ever tried to do.

Try it · the two-minute version
For one minute, do not think about zen.
Each time it crosses your mind, tap the stone. Be honest. Nobody's watching.

The full version takes a whole day, and weekends work best. Be as conventional as you possibly can, and above all don't think about zen. In the evening, sit, find your breath, think whatever you like, and then do one thing nobody has ever done.

Why it might work

The "don't think about zen" rule is a famous experiment in disguise. In 1987 Daniel Wegner asked people not to think of a white bear and to ring a bell whenever they did. They rang it about once a minute. When they were later allowed to think about the bear, it came back even more often.7 Trying to suppress a thought makes it louder. That's why "be normal" turns out to be so hard: the effort keeps catching every original thought. It's also an important lesson for anyone who struggles with intrusive thoughts. Holding them loosely works better than pushing them away.

The creative release at the end of the day is my own guess, not something anyone has studied. It's a fun thing to test on yourself.

Sit with thisCan you try to be ordinary without becoming extraordinary at trying?
Signpost five

The long "lu" promising

The path of inner harmony

Walk this one in Signposts inward (there it’s called “One note”).

The teacher asked the Goddess whether prayers changed what she did. "No," she said. "Whatever I do was going to be done anyway. Prayer is for the one who prays. If you want to thank me, close your eyes and sing one note on the sound lu, for as long as your breath lasts."

"You love a long lu more than any other sound?" "More than any other," said the Goddess.

Try it · sing to the pond
This note 0.0sLongest 0.0sNotes 0
Sing "luuu" on one comfortable note and the pond ripples for as long as it lasts. Your audio stays on your device.
  1. Pick a comfortable note in the middle of your range.
  2. Sing "luuuu" in one smooth tone until you're nearly out of breath. Take a new breath before the note starts to wobble.
  3. Do three rounds. Then do three more with your lips closed, as a hum ("mmmm").
  4. It's even better with other people singing along.
Why it might work

A long sung note is an easy way to get a slow, long exhale, the same lever as the breath practice above. The hum has a specific finding of its own: humming raises nitric oxide in the nose about 15-fold compared with quiet breathing, because the vibration moves air through the sinuses.8 That's where yoga's bhramari ("bee breath") gets its reputation. Whether the nitric oxide does anything for your mood hasn't been shown. The slower breathing almost certainly does.

Sit with thisA note lasts exactly as long as a breath. What else in your life is measured that way?
Signpost six

Fruit fly well studied

The path of all compassion

Walk this one in Signposts inward (there it’s called “Widening circles”).

"Nobody knows the world is tough better than the fruit fly," said the teacher. "She's been chased, swatted and hated, and she still loves the world." He had his class say "I love you" to themselves, then to someone dear, then to someone neutral, and finally to someone they didn't like.

Nobody said his name in the first three rounds. In the fourth, almost everyone did. "So this is what it's like to be a fruit fly," he thought. He went home and practiced until he loved everyone.

Try it · send kindness outward
Start with yourself
Say each phrase three times, out loud or silently, and mean it a little more each time.
Why it might work

The fruit fly follows the traditional order of loving-kindness (metta) meditation: yourself, a loved one, a neutral person, then a difficult one. It's among the best-studied practices on this page. In one trial, seven weeks of practice increased day-to-day positive emotions, and those gains built into lasting resources like stronger social support and fewer illness symptoms.9,10 A correction to how I used to tell this one: I'd promise that if you love everyone, everyone will love you back. That isn't the mechanism. The change happens in you. Whether the fruit fly gets more popular is beside the point.

Go gently

"Difficult" means the coworker who hits reply-all, not someone who hurt you. If the hardest person in your life caused you real harm, leave them out, or work up to them with a therapist. Don't skip being kind to yourself first.

Sit with thisWho would you be if no one were on your "difficult" list?
Signpost seven

Two tortoises promising

The path to true love, plus a solo version called the lake

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

"First, the three questions," said Ms. Tortoise. "What is your name? What do you hide? What is your dream?"

"Mr. Tortoise," said Mr. Tortoise. "Some extra lettuce from you, sometimes. And to wake up next to you and a pile of lettuce."

"That we get to do that for the rest of our lives," said Ms. Tortoise. Then they stopped talking, matched their breathing and looked at each other.

Try it · with someone close
Sit facing each otherTake turns. One asks, the other answers, then switch.

The lake, the solo version: look softly into your own eyes in a mirror for two or three minutes, in good light, blinking normally. Stop if it starts to feel strange (see the note below). In Signposts inward the lake is its own signpost, a gentler thirty seconds.

Why it might work

The three questions are a pocket-sized version of Arthur Aron's well-known "36 questions" study, in which taking turns opening up a little more each time created real closeness between strangers in about 45 minutes.11 The silence has evidence of its own: in a 1989 study, two minutes of mutual eye contact raised strangers' reported affection for each other.12 With someone you already love, it mostly just feels good, after a slightly terrifying first ninety seconds.

Go gently, especially with the mirror

If you stare at your own reflection in dim light for about ten minutes, you'll probably get the "strange-face illusion": your face seems to warp or turn into someone else's.13 It's harmless for most people, but it can be upsetting. Skip the mirror if you've experienced dissociation, depersonalization or psychosis, or if mirrors are hard for you because of body image or an eating disorder. Mirror work can help with those, but it should be done alongside a clinician. And please blink. Your corneas will thank you.

Sit with thisWhat do you hide? Ask yourself that, and then give the true answer.
Signpost eight

Moon early, thin evidence

The path of real friendship

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

"The moon is such a mystery," said the tortoise. "Not to me," said the teacher. "I've practiced moon meditation so long that the moon is an old friend." He explained how it worked. The tortoise said it sounded like a bunch of hooey, and the teacher laughed, because in a way it was.

That night, a villager overheard the tortoise looking up and whispering, "Hello, moon."

Try it · tonight's moon
Hello, moon.
Best done outside, looking up at the real moon. The screen is the training wheels. About 2½ minutes.
Why it might work

Moving your gaze in time with your breath combines focused attention with paced breathing. Yoga's trataka (candle-gazing) practice is built on the same idea, though there's little research on it. The bigger ingredient is probably awe. A few minutes with something vast reliably makes people feel smaller in a good way, more connected and less self-absorbed.14

One thing here is literally true: the moon always shows Earth the same face, so everyone on the planet sees the same moon. (In the Southern Hemisphere it looks upside down.)

Sit with thisEveryone alive tonight sees the same face of the moon. Who might be looking at it with you right now?
Signpost nine

Scribe promising

The path of no regrets

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

"Sometimes I look back and I'm sad," said the student. "I can't enjoy the present." "Then you need paper," said the teacher. "Write the whole story without stopping. Then throw it away."

Later the student asked, "How else can I use this?" "Write down the things you believe," said the teacher. "Throw those away too. You'll find you can live without them."

Try it · write, then release
Nothing you write here is saved or sent anywhere. When you let it go, it's gone.
Why it might work

There are two separate findings here. The first is expressive writing. In James Pennebaker's studies, people who wrote about a hard experience for 15–20 minutes a day over a few days were healthier months later.15 Pooled across about 150 studies, the effect is real but small.16 The second is the throwing away. In a 2013 experiment, people who wrote down negative thoughts about themselves and then physically threw the paper in the trash relied on those thoughts less afterward than people who kept the page.17 That's one lab study, and it hasn't been tested as a treatment. But the teacher's instinct was ahead of the data.

Go gently

Expressive writing often makes you feel worse for an hour or so before you feel better, and that's expected. If the subject is a trauma that overwhelms you, write about it with a therapist's support rather than alone.

Sit with thisIf you can throw away a belief and keep living, was it holding you up or holding you down?
Signpost ten

Cloud well studied

The path of miraculous flight (adjusted for reality)

Walk this one in Signposts inward.

The last signpost always came with a warning: it was the most advanced practice of all, only for the well-prepared, and anyone who tried it too early might hurt themselves. People leaned in. They wanted to fly.

Let's settle this now: you won't levitate. I've checked, repeatedly. But underneath the joke is one of the most useful practices on this page.

Try it · float up
Sit in the room you're in
Your body stays in the chair. Only your viewpoint rises, one level with each slow breath out.
Why it might work

This is self-distancing. Ethan Kross and Özlem Ayduk have spent years showing that looking at a problem from the outside, like a fly on the wall, rather than reliving it from the inside, reduces emotional reactivity and rumination and leads to wiser reasoning.18 Taking the view all the way up borrows a little of the overview effect, the shift astronauts describe after seeing Earth from orbit.19 You don't leave the floor, but your problems shrink back to their actual size. That's the useful kind of flying.

Sit with thisFrom high enough up, every problem is the size of one person in one room. Which size is the true one?

The way out is the way through

You don't get out of the woods by finding the edge. You get out by noticing, again and again, that you wandered off, and then gently coming back. That's the whole practice. The signposts don't take you anywhere else. They bring you back to where you already are.

Over the years, two ideas have stuck with me more than any single technique. Practice works best when it stays new: the moment a meditation becomes a routine you're going through, you're back in the woods. And practice grows when it's shared, so teach one of these to someone this week. I'd suggest the tortoises. Probably not the cloud.

The same signposts, unhurried and full screen: walk Signposts inward. It remembers which ones you’ve walked on this device.

Which signpost do you need today?

Take one breath, then ask.

This page is for education and isn't medical advice. These practices can go alongside real care, but they don't replace it. If you're struggling, in the U.S. you can call or text 988 any time.

References

  1. Zaccaro A, et al. How breath-control can change your life: a systematic review on psycho-physiological correlates of slow breathing. Front Hum Neurosci. 2018;12:353.
  2. Balban MY, et al. Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal. Cell Rep Med. 2023;4(1):100895.
  3. Jacobson E. Progressive Relaxation. University of Chicago Press; 1938. See also Manzoni GM, et al. Relaxation training for anxiety: a ten-years systematic review with meta-analysis. BMC Psychiatry. 2008;8:41.
  4. Severance E, Washburn MF. The loss of associative power in words after long fixation. Am J Psychol. 1907;18(2):182–186.
  5. Lambert WE, Jakobovits LA. Verbal satiation and changes in the intensity of meaning. J Exp Psychol. 1960;60(6):376–383.
  6. Masuda A, Hayes SC, Sackett CF, Twohig MP. Cognitive defusion and self-relevant negative thoughts: examining the impact of a ninety year old technique. Behav Res Ther. 2004;42(4):477–485.
  7. Wegner DM, Schneider DJ, Carter SR, White TL. Paradoxical effects of thought suppression. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1987;53(1):5–13.
  8. Weitzberg E, Lundberg JON. Humming greatly increases nasal nitric oxide. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2002;166(2):144–145.
  9. Fredrickson BL, et al. Open hearts build lives: positive emotions, induced through loving-kindness meditation, build consequential personal resources. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2008;95(5):1045–1062.
  10. Hofmann SG, Grossman P, Hinton DE. Loving-kindness and compassion meditation: potential for psychological interventions. Clin Psychol Rev. 2011;31(7):1126–1132.
  11. Aron A, Melinat E, Aron EN, Vallone RD, Bator RJ. The experimental generation of interpersonal closeness. Pers Soc Psychol Bull. 1997;23(4):363–377.
  12. Kellerman J, Lewis J, Laird JD. Looking and loving: the effects of mutual gaze on feelings of romantic love. J Res Pers. 1989;23(2):145–161.
  13. Caputo GB. Strange-face-in-the-mirror illusion. Perception. 2010;39(7):1007–1008.
  14. Keltner D, Haidt J. Approaching awe, a moral, spiritual, and aesthetic emotion. Cogn Emot. 2003;17(2):297–314.
  15. Pennebaker JW, Beall SK. Confronting a traumatic event: toward an understanding of inhibition and disease. J Abnorm Psychol. 1986;95(3):274–281.
  16. Frattaroli J. Experimental disclosure and its moderators: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull. 2006;132(6):823–865.
  17. Briñol P, Gascó M, Petty RE, Horcajo J. Treating thoughts as material objects can increase or decrease their impact on evaluation. Psychol Sci. 2013;24(1):41–47.
  18. Kross E, Ayduk O. Self-distancing: theory, research, and current directions. Adv Exp Soc Psychol. 2017;55:81–136.
  19. Yaden DB, et al. The overview effect: awe and self-transcendent experience in space flight. Psychol Conscious. 2016;3(1):1–11.